Thursday, July 10, 2014

#59 Empty Shelf Challenge 03 [101 in 1001] (Revisited 2026)

PREAMBLE:  I reread this book in 2026 and have a different take on it.  Because of the stark contrast, I started to completely retool this review.  However, I felt that approach wasn't genuine.  So I hope that reading my first impressions of the work along with my most current thoughts will be helpful.  Thanks in advance for reading. 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

Book: One Thousand Gifts.

Author: Ann Voskamp

Info: Copyright 2010 Zondervan

Where acquired: Checked out of public library.

Why:  When this book first came out, my friends were flocking to read it.  I try never to read something simply based on hype. Plus, I like to read a book before I plunk down money for it.  I saw it at the library a few weeks ago and decided to check it out.

Rating (on a scale of 1-4 hashtags):   #

What it's about:  The central theme of the book is eucharisteo, the Greek word meaning both thankfulness and grace.  The author goes on a journey of finding God's grace and being thankful not only in the spectacular, but the mundane.

Favorite quotes:

  • "Something always comes to fill the empty places.  And when I give thanks for the seemingly microscopic, I make a place for God to grow within me.  This, this, makes me full..." - p. 59
  • "Wherever you are, be all there." - p. 69
  • "'The foremost quality of a trusting disciple is thankfulness'" - p. 153 (A quote of Brennan Manning's book Ruthless Trust.)
What I Liked:
  • The photographs she took during the process sounded very interesting.  I wish she had put some of them in the book, especially those her small daughter took.
  • When her children behaved long enough to have good family times, Voskamp's descriptions were joyful to read.
  • The book did inspire me to start a gratitude journal of my own.
  • I liked the picture on the front cover (I'm pulling at straws here).

What I didn’t like: 

I like where the author was trying to go.  It's a shame that she didn't get there.  In the small pockets of examples of thankfulness, there were larger pockets of confusion.  In one sentence, Voskamp would overflow in gratitude to the Lord. In the next pages, she would go on a litany of guilt and shame because God had been good to her. 

For all the flowery language and vividly descriptive vignettes, the author seems to never get to the point.  I read this whole book hoping for it to get better; it didn't.  In all her encouragement not to get in a hurry, I hurried through the book trying to get to the meat of her message, I never got there.  Her writing reminds me of Lisa Bevere's writings; the depth of the message is lost in the imagery.  I was going to stop reading after the first couple of chapters, but kept on, hoping for the climax of the story or some kind of resolution. There was none.  I felt like I was hitting a piñata that refused to open and spill out any goodies.

There were too many nameless faces and unanswered questions.  The book swam in ambiguity.

The overall tone of the book was so depressing.  I still don't understand what all the hype was about.

This is not a fault of the author, but the book wasn't edited very well.  There were several typographical errors that caused many of the sentences to not make sense.

I know my review sounds harsh, but maybe I just didn't know how to read this book.  Not how, as in not know the physical process of viewing words on a page, but how, as in understanding the voice of the author.  Was this book to be read as a whole, or was each chapter supposed to be a separate entity?  I never could catch the rhythm and tone of Voskamp.  What was she trying to say?

To sum up: My main takeaway from the book was this:  Be thankful and look for God even when you think He's not there.  He's there.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My 2026 revisit.

New rating (on a scale of 1-4 stars):  ✮✮✮✮

I felt led o the Lord to reread this book weeks (maybe months) ago.  I balked as flashes of my first reading carved an acidic pit in my stomach.  I detested this book the first time I read it; why should I read it again?  Looking back at the state of my mental and physical health from twelve years ago shows me that perhaps my self-assessment in the first review was accurate:  the problem wasn't the book; maybe I just wasn't in a good place to receive it.  

I'm taking this a little backwards, but you'll see why.  My interpretation of this work upon my first reading was of a very blessed wife, mom, and writer who was one of those folks who's never satisfied with anything no matter how good it is.  My first dive into this volume was from a place of someone who had nothing reading words from someone who had everything but still wasn't happy.  She had the gifts that society (and too many church people) said was the most important to fulfillment and real womanhood--a husband, kids, a house, a plethora of family and friends who loved her, and, oh yeah, God too.

After rereading chapter one, I now remember why things were hard for her:  A sister killed in an accident, a mom too overcome with sorrow committed to a psychiatric hospital, and a father whose grief turned him away from God.  In the middle is Ann--still going to church and still asking questions while nursing her own lamenting soul alone.

As she began her quest for eucharisteo (grace-filled thanksgiving) in the everyday life, my own heart started opening up.  Yes, the soul is wounded by tragedy and major stressors, but it daily dies by little wounds of hurry, petty slights, and chronic ingratitude.  In 2014 when I read the book the first time, I wasn't nursing my own wounded soul; I was doing everything to ignore it, stuff it down deep in a hole, or drown it if I could.  I wish I'd had the capacity to engage in this art of soul keeping then.  Sure, I tried my own 1000 gifts list, but I don't even remember if I made it to 100, much less 1000.  Plus, those pages are long gone to quietly biodegrade in the Calhoun County (AL) landfill.

I think one of the big helps this time with better understanding the tome was deciding to read the audiobook version.  My last foray was with the print version.  The audio, narrated by Voskamp herself, gave me more insight into the tone of the book.  I could hear her heart and better grasp her meaning.

Another big help is that my own reading and writing have matured over the past 12 years, so her "flowery language" hit just right in my heart.  The fun of the soap bubbles, the cheese, and chasing after the harvest moon were my favorite snapshots of gratitude.  This time I could see the pictures she painted with her words.  When my own creativity was stifled, I couldn't interpret or appreciate the creativity of someone else.

I didn't understand that when Jesus spoke of gaining the world but losing one's soul (Mark 8:36), He wasn't just talking to those who didn't have a relationship with Him;  He was speaking to any of us substituting anything of the world (items, people, attitudes, addictions, etc), for true communion with Him.  Voskamp was losing her soul in anxiety and grief; at the time I was losing my to addiction, depression, and thoughts of suicide.  So, was I trying to dine at a table where I wasn't welcome?  No, I was invited to set my own table and bask in Christ's personal Eucharistic feast for me. Part of setting that table was getting help with my own wounded soul and learning how to heal and nourish it. 

Am I now going to sing the undying praises of this book?  No, there are still things I don't understand or agree with.  However, this isn't what the author was presenting, or even asking of the reader.  My first slog though One Thousand Gifts was as one looking through an instruction manual, but the point of the book wasn't to tell me how I should live.  This was simple memoir that showed how she lived.  I didn't know memoir was the genre:  Goodreads placed it in "Christian living" and "self-help" genres among others.  Voskamp didn't set up her life as an exemplar to mimic.  Just as my story doesn't look like hers, my "gifts" won't look like hers either.  The particular gifts aren't the focus; it is seeing the Giver within the gift and being grateful for both.

No comments:

Post a Comment